Home › News › Local News
Animal euthanizing lessens
Spay and neuter clinics credited with the decline
Julie Peters / Special to The Star Summer Massey holds a kitten while it is examined to determine if it needs to be neutered at Valley Veterinary Clinic's in Simi Valley.
Photos by Julie Peters / Special to The Star Susan King, a registered veterinary technician, monitors the heart rate of a cat that has been given anesthesia before surgery at Valley Veterinary Clinic in Simi Valley.
Stray cats, runaway pets and tons of kittens.
For years, controlling the number of domestic and feral cats in Ventura County has been an overwhelming task, with thousands of animals being euthanized annually by Ventura County Animal Regulation. But that number has steadily declined with the efforts of animal rescue groups working on shelter adoptions and fewer unwanted animals thanks to spay and neuter organizations, county officials say.
Lowell Novy, founder of Valley Veterinary Clinic in Simi Valley, has offered regularly scheduled free and low-cost spay and neuter clinics for the past 10 years.
"We've reduced our kill rate from Simi Valley by 85 percent," in that time, he said.
Programs elsewhere in the area, including the Oxnard Veterinary Hospital, Mercy Crusade in Oxnard, the Spay/Neuter Animal Network in Ventura, Concerned People for Animals in Camarillo and the Calabasas-based Herman Bennett Foundation, also are having an effect.
The organizations provide free or low-cost spay and neuter services or vouchers to the public and contract with veterinarians who accept the vouchers.
Taking cats seriously'
The efforts are helping to diminish the number of animals being destroyed in the county, said Kathy Jenks, director of county Animal Regulation, which provides animal control for most cities and unincorporated areas of the county. Its main shelter is in Camarillo.
"The unwanted births aren't happening. You don't have so many free to good home' ads in the newspaper, and you don't see kids giving away free kittens in front of stores.
"People are being a little more responsible and finally taking cats seriously," she said.
The decreasing number of euthanizings prove her point. In Ventura County in 1985-86, 7,306 cats were destroyed by Animal Regulation, according to the agency's Web site. That compares to 2,157 in 2006-07, despite an increased county population.
Reducing California's pet overpopulation — last year more than 500,000 dogs and cats were euthanized in the state — is a challenge for communities as well as veterinarians.
But it's not an impossible job, Novy said. The key is continuity; once-a-year neutering clinics aren't going to make a difference, particularly with the feral cat population.
One unspayed feral cat having two litters a year, and those litters having litters, could eventually total thousands of offspring, said Jan Feingold of Oxnard Veterinary Hospital.
Volunteers required
At a spay day clinic this summer, Novy and a team of veterinarians — his daughter Deb Bitterly, and Lisa Goldstein, contract veterinarians formerly on staff at Valley Veterinary; staff member Douglass Kramer, and Sara Strongin of Las Vegas — spayed and neutered close to 100 cats.
About 20 volunteers, including veterinary technicians, Novy's visiting daughter Judy Holmes of Milwaukee, her three children and Bitterly's two children assisted them.
Members of the Herman Bennett Foundation handed out vouchers for free or low-cost altering services, goody bags with educational materials and cat supplies.
Volunteers are the mainstay of the clinic's efforts, which date back to 1996, when registered vet technician Diane Bentz approached Novy with the spay day concept that led to monthly clinics for several years.
Since hosting its first large-scale no-cost/low-cost event in 1997, Novy estimates 15,000 to 18,000 cats have been altered through the program.
In addition to special days set aside for community outreach, each Monday Bitterly does surgery on an average of 30 more cats with funding from the Valley Veterinary Clinic Charitable Non-Profit Corp., which was formed in 2003.
With local animal control agencies in the state forced to spend more than $250 million every year to catch, control and euthanize unwanted dogs and cats, California legislators last year introduced a bill requiring mandatory spaying and neutering.
Grass-roots works
Assembly Bill 1634, however, was rejected on the floor of the Senate, a victory for organized animal groups that fought the mandatory designation.
The California Responsible Pet Ownership Act, co-written by Assemblyman Pedro Nava, D-Santa Barbara, was touted as a humane and taxpayer-friendly solution to combating the nearly 1 million unwanted cats and dogs entering the state's animal shelters annually.
But it was significantly diluted from its original form and failed to garner the support needed, said William Grant, president of the California Veterinary Medical Association.
But despite the bill's defeat, Grant said, the battle to diminish the number of unwanted animals by promoting altering is making headway, community by community.
He's seen the number of euthanized animals fall in Orange County, where he and his father launched a spay and neuter campaign from their Garden Grove veterinary practice more than 25 years ago.
"It's more effective to have people passionate and compassionate (about spaying and neutering) because this is the right thing to do. They can make it work."
Making a difference
With Simi cat euthanizings down — 170 were done by Animal Regulation in 2006-07 — Valley Veterinary now conducts only four to six spay day clinics annually.
But in Oxnard, the county's largest city, the number of cats being euthanized was 892 in 2006-07, as reported on Animal Regulation's Web site.
That's why Feingold, joined by Bitterly, conducts once-a-month free or low-cost spay and neuter clinics, averaging about 50 cats each session. He also does spaying and neutering as needed throughout the week.
The need in Oxnard was also the reason the nonprofit Mercy Crusade opened its spay and neuter clinic there in 2001. It provides altering for domestic cats at $20 for males and $30 for females.
"We do notice a difference, and the rescue groups are noticing a difference" in the number of animals being taken to the shelter and euthanized, said Mercy Crusade President Lois Osborne.
Other organizations involved in spay and neuter efforts include Animal Regulation and the Humane Society of Ventura County.
Feingold said the effort and cost involved in fighting pet overpopulation are worth it.
"Every little bit helps; but one day won't solve the problem. It has to be an ongoing effort," he said.
Recruiting effort
Valley Veterinary Clinic Charitable Non-Profit Corp. volunteers have been recruiting veterinarians throughout the state to start dedicated low-cost spay day programs of their own.
To help them get started, Bentz said, she, a veterinarian and other volunteers will go to the interested facility for a time to assist with the day's spaying and neutering and will provide the initial supplies needed.
The corporation's outreach programs are now under way in Yreka, Santa Maria, Oxnard and the Conejo Valley, Novy said. Valley Veterinary Clinic Charitable Non-Profit Corp. recently sent letters to 250 veterinarians statewide offering to help. One veterinarian each in Stockton, Bakersfield, Pico Rivera and Ventura responded.
"Four out of 250 is better than none," Bentz said. "Typically, when we started 10 years ago, no one was really interested."
Not discouraged by the lack of response, the semi-retired Novy plans to stay the course.
"Anyone that wants us, we're going to be there. But if they don't have any local vets willing, it's impossible for us to take on the world," he said. "It needs to be done on a local level, community by community."
Posted by SoSad on October 5, 2008 at 10:23 a.m. (Suggest removal)
That's great! We need to step up and be responsible for our pets.
Posted by jill on October 5, 2008 at 11:44 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Great news to hear that euthanizations are down and people are becoming more responsible and compassionate. Euthanizations will someday hopefully be a thing of the past. Please stop breeding your dogs. This is a very moving video "In Hope: An Animal Shelter Story" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYBz2g...
Posted by smithjc on October 5, 2008 at 2:14 p.m. (Suggest removal)
i wouldn't tell people to "stop breeding your dogs", but rather "stop breeding irresponsibly".
i would hate to think of a world without dogs. my belief is that a house doesn't become a home until there's a dog in it.
Posted by SueSue on October 5, 2008 at 2:41 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Good job, great effort.
My house is a home because I have my rats. Any animal can make a place a home and responsible ownership is everyones job.
It takes a village to maintain animal control.
I love Valley Vet, Dr. Gonzolas has helped all my rats be healthier and has been very gentle when they had to be put down.
Dr. Novy has been a main staple in animal responsibility in the community, we in Simi Valley know him well. We applaud him and all who work with him in the effort to make everyone aware of the problem and how to re a responsible animal owner.
Posted by Brownpride on October 5, 2008 at 4:15 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Stop breeding your Pitbulls and Chiuaua's.
Posted by Peggys_Daddy on October 5, 2008 at 4:38 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Dear mad-as-hell
I too am an animal nut, and to your comment of "$2 for a shell, $25 each to bury them total one time bill less than $400. Hell most of you animal nuts don't treat people half as well". I say that's not true! Why I would spend at least twice as much if not more to shoot you if you needed shooting, and it were legal. Yes, I've had to euthanize an animal, but my test for euthanasia is, that if an animal can never regain a quality of life and is suffering, it's time to pull the plug. If however an animal can recover an live a full happy life, which is what we are really talking about, I believe it's worth the money and effort.
I'm sorry that that you view animals and humans "far" differently. I believe your problem stems from either ignorance of animals or you have pseudo-sociopathic tendencies and I hope someday you receive help.
Posted by jill on October 5, 2008 at 5:50 p.m. (Suggest removal)
smithjc,
People could stop breeding dogs now and in five years we would still have dogs in the pound being put to sleep. Until they are not being euthanized because of overpopulation, people should not be allowed to breed dogs. Thankfully, we will never be a world without dogs, but right now a large percentage of the dogs in this world are being neglected, dumped and euthanized. For every litter of puppies from a breeder so they can make their $$, the same amount are in cement cell at a pound awaiting death. So sad.
Posted by smithjc on October 5, 2008 at 6:26 p.m. (Suggest removal)
jill,
my last two dogs came from the pound, and i've adopted three from the pound altogether. all my others have been strays that wandered into the "right" place. each of the strays that i adopted had been obviously abused before i found them. each of them, pound puppy and stray alike, found a loving home. this system works for me, because i don't "need" purebred dogs. some people, for whatever reason, feel the need to have a purebred dog. oddly enough, these are commonly people that need to have "bunnies" for wives, status cars and status homes.
for me, i'll drive my dodge and keep my mutts.
Posted by Bud_Bundy on October 6, 2008 at 12:36 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Now if we could just stop the irresponsible breeding habits of some humans, we'd be all better off.
Posted by jill on October 7, 2008 at 1:02 p.m. (Suggest removal)
"for me, i'll drive my dodge and keep my mutts."
And I'll keep my Ford and my mutts! The welfare of homeless animals is more important to me than owning a purebred. Some people out there who claim to be "animal lovers" really don't care how they affect animals in the least. For them, it's all about "me, me, me."
Article discussions on this site are to support community debates of issues related to our stories and editorials.
Discussions should not stray from the subject of the story or editorial.
We do not allow the following:
- Posts that degrade others on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation or disability.
- Disparaging remarks, abusive language or obscene comments.
- Threats, whether obvious or veiled.
We reserve the right to delete threads and/or ban users for these or other reasons we deem necessary.
Opinions are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.










There are 10 comments to this article.
Comments are found beneath the Yahoo! ad below.