Home › Opinion › Opinion
Forgoing pesticides will help clean air
Re: your May 1 article, "Despite progress, air quality still poor":
The American Lung Association gave Ventura County an F grade for its smog levels.
The day before, April 30, The Star had an article, "Fumigant limits to begin on Thursday," about the federal mandate that local farmers reduce their use of crop fumigants that cause smog and have helped earn us our F rating. The Star reports that Rob Roy, president of the Ventura County Agricultural Association, said his clients will focus on the lawsuit that seeks to reverse the regulation.
Local growers knew for years regulations would require them to reduce the use of these polluting chemicals to 20 percent of 1991 levels, but increased fumigant use instead. Now, they claim agriculture won't survive without them. Growers want to use enough fumigants to put 2.5 million pounds of volatile organic compounds into our air this year. That is just from fumigant pesticides.
In the past couple of months, there have been articles about air pollution and how the Air Pollution Control District has worked diligently to reduce air pollution. It's my understanding that major smog contributors such as the port, aircraft and agriculture are outside the scope of APCD. Without some pollution reduction from those sectors, Ventura County may never get our smog problem under control.
An article in The Star's Business section March 23, "Getting in a stink over higher fertilizer prices," was about how a 100 percent price increase in fertilizer prices is hitting growers. One reason stated was soaring oil costs — something we are all feeling the impact of now. Years ago, reports showed the cost of oil affects farmers the most in the use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers, more than fueling trucks and tractors farmers rely on. With oil prices increasing, farmers can expect chemical inputs to increase.
I want to suggest that, instead of spending their money on lawsuits fighting sensible regulations, Roy and the Ventura Agricultural Association use their wealth and influence to support research that will help growers transition away from dependence on air polluting petrochemical products. Oil prices probably aren't going down and demand for organic products is increasing. Growers will have to change to prosper. Fighting to maintain oil-dependent, polluting agricultural production is a losing battle.
We can make better consumer choices to encourage growers to farm without harming our air quality. Conventional strawberry production accounts for the highest use of smog-forming fumigants and other polluting pesticides. Paying homage to this fruit with an annual festival and driving cars to get there is a celebration of pollution. To get better air quality and get rid of that F grade, we all need to change.
— Deborah Bechtel lives in Camarillo.





Posted by Face on May 9, 2008 at 1:27 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Forgoing pesticides will help clean air, and reduce agricultural output at a time when the world is experiencing a food shortage. Now is not the time to cut back food production, soon we will be seeing 10s of millions of starving people on t.v. then what will you have to say? Wait until the food crisis is over before you start figuring ways to cut production for any reason.
Posted by Tom_Johnston on May 9, 2008 at 5:24 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Ok...again...if the farmers had more or less seen the "handwriting on the wall" and moved towards some kind of gradual phase-in, they would not be in this mess now. So much for stubborn resistance to the tides of change.
Then again...Ventura County gets a "F" for air quality? Honey, go drive to LA to see some serious air pollution. I'm not saying that some days are bad, particularly in Simi Valley or T Oaks....but just drive over the grade into the SFV to see what it could be like.
And please...I don't think for one minute that the total cessation of agriculture in Ventura County, catastrophic as it would be to our local econom, would have ANY impact at all on world food shortages or hunger. The masses of the world currently experiencing this don't eat our strawberries, citrus, lettuce, avocados, green onions or much of anything else grown here.
As to the viability of agriculture without such heavy reliance on pesticides etc, go check out your local Farmers Market where nearly all of the produce is grown in a more environmentally "PC" fashion. Prices can be a bit more, that's true, but the point is, it can be done.
Posted by mmshoot on May 9, 2008 at 6:11 a.m. (Suggest removal)
My only guess is that the American Lung society was only considering over-all air polution output per number of people living in the county. A grade of F could only mean including petroleum production and processing, increasing population, a stronger and more holistic economy, and the normal progression of affluence.
Fertilizers should be considered for the impact it may have on the soil, not the air. I wonder where Deborah Bechtel as been if she thinks our (Ventura County) air pollution is bad. It's not a long trip south and east to take a look at Los Angeles county.
Posted by mmshoot on May 9, 2008 at 6:59 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Should read: "Pesticides should be considered..."
I can be extended to say that fumigant use has more impact on the eco-system in general but is doubtfully a major contributor to air pollution.
(Requires free registration.)
Comments on this site are to be used for the discussion and/or debate of issues related to our stories and editorials.
Comments should not stray from the subject of the story or editorial.
We don't allow the following:
We reserve the right to delete comments and/or ban users for these or other reasons we deem necessary.
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.