Home › News › County News
St. Francis Dam disaster: A tale of failure, tragedy and heroism
Photo by Eric Parsons
For the third time in the past decade, John Nichols of Santa Paula is helping to put together the California Oil Museum exhibit on the St. Francis Dam disaster. "It's endlessly fascinating," he says of the 1928 event. Enlarged antique photos of the aftermath will be part of the exhibit.
Multimedia: St. Francis Dam
Video illustration: Path of Destruction
A digital look at the St. Francis Dam disaster and the toll it took on its path of destruction.
Watch now »
Video: Fall of the St. Francis dam
A local historian and a former rescue worker retell the story of one of the worst disasters in the county’s history.Watch now »
Images from the St. Francis Dam.
View slide show »
San Francisquito Canyon Road is a two-lane mountain road that winds and dips through the Angeles National Forest, heading north out of the Santa Clara River Valley.
It's easy to drive right past the site of the worst disaster in Southern California's history.
The ruins of the St. Francis Dam are a few hundred yards from the road. Even after parking and hiking down an abandoned bit of roadway, a visitor might only notice them once they're underfoot. The huge chunks of concrete in the creek bed are overgrown and hard to distinguish from the natural contours of the canyon. Here and there, a piece of steel rebar sticks up out of the rock and the dry grass.
Eighty years ago, the St. Francis Dam stood across this canyon and held back 12 billion gallons of water.
Then suddenly it didn't.
The dam broke a few minutes before midnight on March 12, 1928. The water behind it, once destined for the bathtubs and drinking glasses of the people of Los Angeles, roared down San Francisquito Canyon and turned west along the Santa Clara River through Piru, Fillmore, Santa Paula and Saticoy before reaching the sea.
Along the way, it picked up trees, boulders, houses, livestock and people. The flood killed at least 500 people and left thousands homeless.
Lucille Matzen was part of the first wave of rescue workers. In 1928, she was Lucille Johnson, a 20-year-old Salvation Army captain in Glendale.
She was called to Santa Paula on the morning of March 13. The low-lying parts of town were devastated. Bodies floated in the river and jutted out of the mud.
Waiting out the flood
"It was such a ghastly sight," said Matzen, who lives in East Ventura now. "I'll never forget it as long as I live."
Zanada von Doeren of Oxnard was 5 years old when the dam broke, but she remembers it, too. Her parents put her in the family car, and they drove up the Conejo Grade to wait out the flood.
"We just went up there and stayed until they gave the all-clear," she said. "We were lucky; we didn't lose anything. It was the people in Santa Paula and Fillmore who lost everything."
The Ante family in Santa Paula lost almost everything. Lupe, their 11-year-old daughter, is now Lupe Simmons and lives in Ventura with her son.
She remembers her father waking her that night and leading the family out of their Seventh Street home and uphill. She doesn't remember how they found out the dam had broken.
When they walked back a few hours later, their house was gone. They had to live in a tent near the river until they could rebuild.
"There were rows and rows and rows of tents, like the ones soldiers would live in," Simmons said.
There is no single answer as to why the St. Francis Dam broke. By modern standards, its construction and materials were subpar, and the canyon floor wasn't suitable to support it.
"It was built on top of an ancient landslide," said John Nichols of Santa Paula, who wrote a book about the disaster in 2002. "It looked like a good location, because the canyon is very narrow right there, but it was unstable."
Geologists at the time, though, found no fault with the dam or its location. The city of Los Angeles built dams and aqueducts all over the state, and while there were other failures, there was never a catastrophe like the St. Francis Dam.
William Mulholland, the head of the predecessor to the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, oversaw the design and construction of the dam and took full responsibility for its collapse. Mulholland was never the same; the father of L.A.'s modern water system retired shortly afterward and lived the rest of his life in near-seclusion.
Every five years, there's renewed interest in the disaster. The California Oil Museum in Santa Paula holds an anniversary exhibit, and the survivors again find themselves sought out by journalists and historians. There are fewer of them every time, of course. Simmons, now 91, calls herself "the last of the Mohicans."
For the third time in the past decade, Nichols is helping to put together the Oil Museum's exhibit. It opens Sunday and runs through July 27.
"It's endlessly fascinating," Nichols said. "You've got a tragedy, an engineering failure, a psychological drama as far as how it affected William Mulholland and then the heroism of how people reacted."
Nichols is fascinated by the elusive nature of heroism, and he's made it the focus of the latest exhibit.
In every town along the flood's path, people put their lives at risk to warn their neighbors of the impending disaster and help them reach higher ground. Some of those people were firefighters or police officers, but many were just ordinary citizens, Nichols said.
Monument in Santa Paula
They might not have been angels — "What if you went home after saving somebody and you kicked your dog?" Nichols pondered — but they were heroes because they rose to the occasion.
There's a monument to their deeds in downtown Santa Paula, a sculpture called "The Watchers" that depicts two motorcycle policemen who rode through town spreading the word.
There are unknown heroes, too. One woman had the grisly task of photographing all of the dead bodies at the morgue, so their families could identify them.
Her name has been lost, but Nichols' exhibit recounts her work.
"It fades in people's minds, and in some cases it fades into obscurity," he said. "Here's a significant disaster in our history, and most of the reaction I get when I tell people about it is, How come I never heard of this? Why isn't this taught in school?' I just don't know."






Posted by garion246 on March 12, 2008 at 11:04 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Thanks for the history lesson.
Posted by mykdzmom2 on March 12, 2008 at 11:18 a.m. (Suggest removal)
I attended public schools in Santa Paula in the 60's and 70's, and never once heard about this disaster. The first I learned of it was when the Union Oil Museum did the exhibit mentioned in this article. I attended Isbell school, which is featured in many of the historical photos, and did not know it was part of this major disaster. To Santa Paula School District and Santa Paula Union High School District: you need to tell your students about the dramatic event that happened in their town. Many of the houses shown in the historical record are still standing today, and can be identified easily. Some of those evacuated are still living. Thank you Star for telling this story, it needs to be remembered. There are many lessons to be learned, not only about the tragedy itself, but also about the amazing accomplishments of William Mulholland in bringing water to Los Angeles, and the sad way his career ended.
Posted by JeannetteMedrano on March 12, 2008 at 12:06 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Now my children can have a clearing vision of why the monument stands in Santa Paula. We will be visiting the museum. Thanks for the story!
Posted by Equitable_Enforcer on March 12, 2008 at 2:22 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Good story, Tony. Thanks!!!
Posted by Legal_American on March 12, 2008 at 10:12 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Excellent Article VCS…
The collapse of the St. Francis Dam is the worst American civil engineering failure of the 20th century and remains the second-greatest loss of life in California's history, after the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake and fires.
Throughout 1926 and 1927, several cracks appeared in the dam, some of which leaked muddy water as the reservoir was filled. The cracks and leaks were inspected by Mulholland, who dismissed them as normal for a concrete dam the size of the St. Francis. On March 7, 1928, the reservoir was filled to capacity for the first time, whereupon dam keeper Tony Harnischfeger spotted new cracks and leaks and contacted Mulholland, who again dismissed them as normal.
Posted by dpgerman on March 13, 2008 at 4:23 p.m. (Suggest removal)
My great grand mother was the post mistress in Newhall at the time. She had visited the dam the day before and taken some pictures. If she hadn't told us I doubt that I would have ever known about it.
Posted by salasgirl on March 13, 2008 at 7:01 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Although I do not work at Santa Paula High School anymore, I do know that the Agricultural and Human Resources academies started in the 90's have dedicated themselves to assisting the Oil Museum in organizing and presenting historical events that happened in Santa Paula and or included Santa Paula Residents. Many teachers and students have worked many hours to make sure Santa Paula history and local history is remembered for future generations.http://www.sespe.com/damd...
Posted by harloe521 on March 13, 2008 at 9:28 p.m. (Suggest removal)
I was 2yrs old when the dam broke..Was told about
how Luther Williams and Thorton Edwards..Rod there motorcycle thru Harvard Blvd. & warned the
People of the Dam having broke and to move to higher ground..Edwards later became Police Chief and upon retirement moved to Hollywood and was in
many Movies..Luther Williams was our.. Hero..Because later on when the Carnivals would come to Town..He always won the wresling matches with there bad guys.. A long time ago..
Posted by Old_Fart on March 13, 2008 at 11:37 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Excellent Story and History Lesson
(Requires free registration.)
Article discussions on this site are to support community debates of issues related to our stories and editorials.
Discussions should not stray from the subject of the story or editorial.
We do not allow the following:
We reserve the right to delete threads and/or ban users for these or other reasons we deem necessary.
Opinions are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.