Weather | Beachcam
Login | Contact Us | Staff | Site Map | Archives | Alerts | Electronic Edition | Subscribe to the paper

HomeEducationEducation: College

Schools, lacking funds for nursing programs, reject eligible applicants

Urgent need


Download Podcast  Download this story as a podcast!
CSU Channel Islands nursing student Racquel Biascan of Camarillo tends to patient Rose Harris at Los Robles Hospital & Medical Center's East Campus in Thousand Oaks. CSUCI has enough funding for only 37 nursing students this fall.

Photo by James Glover II


CSU Channel Islands nursing student Racquel Biascan of Camarillo tends to patient Rose Harris at Los Robles Hospital & Medical Center's East Campus in Thousand Oaks. CSUCI has enough funding for only 37 nursing students this fall.

CSU Channel Islands nursing student Aileen Gonzalez of Camarillo works at Los Robles Hospital & Medical Center's East Campus in Thousand Oaks. Hospitals need nurses to replace an aging work force and cope with a shortage that will likely get worse as baby boomers need healthcare.

Photo by James Glover II


CSU Channel Islands nursing student Aileen Gonzalez of Camarillo works at Los Robles Hospital & Medical Center's East Campus in Thousand Oaks. Hospitals need nurses to replace an aging work force and cope with a shortage that will likely get worse as baby boomers need healthcare.

College freshman Rachel Weller could be the answer to Ventura County's nursing shortage. She's smart, motivated and committed to a profession that desperately needs new recruits.

The 18-year-old from Moorpark with a 3.46 grade-point average applied to enter the nursing program this fall at CSU Channel Islands in Camarillo, along with 312 other students. Earlier this month, 276 of them ripped open mail from the university only to find rejection notices, though program administrators say many of them are qualified and should have been accepted.

The barrier is money. The state of California and various grants generated enough funding for only 37 students to begin the three-year program this fall. However, hospitals, clinics and public health departments need more young nurses to replace an aging work force and cope with a shortage that will likely get worse as baby boomers need more healthcare.

"It's heartbreaking. They were excellent candidates. They'd make good nurses. We just don't have room," said Dr. Karen Jensen, director of the nursing program at CSUCI. "We're on a bad path with the collision of the nursing shortage and the boomers. It's a recipe for disaster."

An increasingly backed-up educational pipeline blocks would-be nurses from their chosen career. Moorpark College's nursing program carries a waiting list of 400 students. Ventura College's program has 250 students waiting for a spot. Similar waiting lists can be found throughout the state.

The numbers are inflated because students sign up for more than one waiting list. But if all the students who wanted to become nurses could get into a program, the state's problems would be over, said Deloras Jones, executive director of the California Institute for Nursing and Health Care in Berkeley.

"We have the solution in front of us, but we can't fund it," she said. "We're only able to admit 40 percent of the qualified candidates in California. In your area, it's even worse."

Moving on

Weller has wanted to be a nurse since her first year of high school. She enrolled at CSUCI because the university opened a new nursing program last fall. She was bitterly disappointed to get the rejection notice but was hurt more by an accompanying notice. It asked her to choose a new career path.

"This is what I want to do," said Weller, who plans to reapply to the nursing school next year. "Why should I have to change my major? I don't want to change my major."

Rejected nursing students dot the 6-year-old campus at the edge of the Santa Monica Mountains. Sitting with friends at the Islands Cafe, 19-year-old Jasmine Frazier said she decided on a nursing career because nurses showed her how to cope when she received a diagnosis of chronic bronchitis. She's still determined to make her career goal and plans on transferring to CSU San Bernardino.

Two tables over, a girl in a black T-shirt said she opened her rejection letter in her dorm room.

"I kind of freaked out. I started crying because I spent so much time studying. I feel like all my time was wasted," she said, announcing plans to change her major to computer studies. "I'm not going to be a nurse. I kind of felt like I had to accept it and move on."

People want to be registered nurses because of the chance to help others, guaranteed job security and a median salary of about $68,000. Nursing advocates worry the surge in interest won't last long if schools can't accept more students.

"Nursing is going to get a very bad rap," Jones said. "When that happens, we're not going to have people wanting to get on a waiting list."

Not making the grade

New nurses are needed because the Ventura County shortage was ranked in 2004 as fifth worst in a state that had the lowest ratio of nurses to residents in the nation, according to a federal study.

The report card by Jones' Institute for Nursing and Health Care gave the county an F because it had only 3,490 registered nurse positions. That's about 430 for every 100,000 county residents.

The numbers have climbed. A 2006 state survey reported 4,330 registered nursing jobs in the county. The ratio of 541 nurses for every 100,000 in population would have earned the county a D in the 2004 report card.

The shortage means hospitals pay more to go outside the area to find temporary nurses and meet California regulations requiring one nurse for every five general care patients.

"Basically, we steal from other states," said Nancy Seck, a nursing administrator from Los Robles Hospital & Medical Center in Thousand Oaks.

Clinics, nursing homes, urgent care centers and public health departments also struggle, running short of staffs, hiring temporary help or using licensed vocational nurses instead of registered nurses.

Even with the huge waiting lists and rejections, more students are entering nursing in Ventura County because of expansions at the community colleges and the launch of the CSUCI program a year ago. State officials cite a $90 million initiative that started in 2005 as a prime reason graduation rates across the state have increased 61 percent over the past three years.

The cost of nursing

Corinne Grandpre of Camarillo attends a therapeutic communication lab for nursing students at CSU Channel Islands. The university rejected 276 applicants this month.

Photo by Juan Carlo Mendoza


Corinne Grandpre of Camarillo attends a therapeutic communication lab for nursing students at CSU Channel Islands. The university rejected 276 applicants this month.

Other observers say the shortage is improving because of a state law that took effect five years ago and pushes hospitals to follow ratios that in general care units mean one nurse for every five patients.

The gains have not ended the concerns of nursing leaders who worry about aging baby boomers. Not only will more people need hospital care but also a huge chunk of the nursing force will enter retirement. Some observers predict the shortage will become a crisis in about 2010, threatening hospitals and potentially forcing the state to make dramatic changes in patient care.

"They're going to have to find a solution other than nurses to take care of people," said Jensen.

The pipeline is clogged in part because nursing programs are expensive to run, with each student at Channel Islands costing the college about $10,000.

"You can educate a heck of a lot more English majors than nursing majors for that same dollar," said Jones.

Other barriers include limited classroom space at community colleges and problems in finding enough hospital sites so students can do clinical training. The biggest problem is faculty.

CSUCI doesn't have the money to hire the additional teachers needed to enroll more students. Even with money, those teaching positions are hard to fill because the state pays new professors about $75,000, much less than hospitals pay experienced nurses with advanced degrees.

"There are masters and doctorate people in the faculty who are making less than their students once the students graduate," said Lee Abramo, a registered nurse and director of education at Los Robles Hospital & Medical Center.

Area hospitals already subsidize the cost of education at the community colleges and the university. They paid $400,000 to a partnership program that allowed 33 nursing students to enroll simultaneously at Moorpark College and CSUCI, taking classes at both campuses.

Some nursing advocates think hospitals should contribute more, but Jensen is trying to find other sources. The university pursues every grant possible and approaches everyone from Rotary Club members to philanthropists for scholarship money or other donations.

Permanent funding needed

Rachel Weller was disappointed by the CSUCI rejection but hurt more by an accompanying notice. It asked her to choose a new career path. "This is what I want to do," she said. "I don't want to change my major."

Photo by Juan Carlo Mendoza


Rachel Weller was disappointed by the CSUCI rejection but hurt more by an accompanying notice. It asked her to choose a new career path. "This is what I want to do," she said. "I don't want to change my major."

State officials say the governor's $90 million initiative has already expanded capacity at community colleges and universities and will bring 10,900 new nurses into the work force by 2010. They cite programs that pay off college loans for students who go on to become professors and private-public partnerships that bring hospitals and schools together.

Observers say the initiative has helped but worry that much of the money available to schools is tied to grants that will eventually expire. They say more permanent funding is needed.

But the state is in the grips of a $16 billion deficit, meaning nursing schools are competing for general fund money with high schools, law enforcement and everyone else.

Stephanie Leach, an assistant secretary of the California Labor and Workforce Development Agency, said the problems involve much more than budgets. The state has to find ways to restructure the pipeline and not just use money as Band-Aids.

"You can throw as much money as you want, and it's not going to fix it," she said.

But Jensen of CSUCI worries about a proposed budget cut that she says could eventually squeeze even more students out of the classrooms. She said money is what the program needs.

As for the students, they want any solution that will get them into a nursing school.

"Nursing is needed so bad," said Olivia Tilleard of Ocean-side, a sophomore who was rejected from the CSUCI program. "There's just a lot of people who need help health-wise, and there's a lot of people who want to help, but there's just not enough room education-wise, which I think is ridiculous."

Discussions

There are 13 comments to this article.   

Comments are found beneath the Yahoo! ad below.

Comments

Posted by ssakoian on April 20, 2008 at 8:03 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Any projections on what the world will be like when the baby boomers are extinct?

Posted by ItsMyOpinion on April 20, 2008 at 8:25 a.m. (Suggest removal)

ssakoian - Language will digress even further into ungrammatical lingo; the concept of a strong work ethic will go out the window; "It's not my job" will be the normal response; "team" will cease to exist in favor of "me, me, me." I see it already. When we're no longer around to temper things and insist on a modicum of responsibility from others, too many will take the path of least resistance and go with the general flow--which will not be in a positive direction. Just my opinion.

Posted by Face on April 20, 2008 at 9:35 a.m. (Suggest removal)

We don't need more money for Nursing Education, we need more money so we can throw more Diversity, Earth, and Cultural Sensitivity Days. These schools need to spend their money on Education and Curriculum, not Socialism and Propaganda. BTW does anyone know what generation the term "ME Generation" is attributed to?

Posted by NavalAviator on April 20, 2008 at 11:02 a.m. (Suggest removal)

This shortage of funds, and of teachers, is why my company moves nursing students to Canadian nursing schools on Canadian Study permits all the time.

Why fight it, the 4-year Canadian nursing education is parallel that of the United States. They welcome Americans.

Posted by bearbigdog2 on April 20, 2008 at 11:30 a.m. (Suggest removal)

C.M.H. is planning on building on to their hospital. Where are they going to get the nurses to fill the positions? My neice has almost completed her R.N. in Toledo, Ohio. A person might have to re-locate instead of changing their career. Telling someone to change their career path is so cold. If a student is paying the tuition to attend college and the college cannot promise that you will graduate in the students choosen degree? Why is CSUCI promoting a degree that students cannot get?

Posted by Tom_Johnston on April 20, 2008 at 11:59 a.m. (Suggest removal)

While I won't go so far as some, I do have share criticism of higher education priorities.

While there has been some variation over the years, a shortage of available slots in nursing education programs are nothing new. They have been around for decades.

The failure of local and other institutions to adapt to these needs is clear. There is no excuse for not being able to accept more students not only in nursing but the other allied health fields such a Imaging/Radiology, Respiratory Care, Laboratory Science and more.

Nursing is of course, the core of the workforce in hospitals, however all these fields currently experience shortages of qualified applicants.

Posted by beachgurl on April 21, 2008 at 11:38 a.m. (Suggest removal)

I graduated from nursing school way back in '88 during a "nursing shortage", as long as you could speak in complete sentances, had a diploma and didn't drool during your interview you were pretty much hired. I have been in the field now for 20 years and the "shortage" continues unabated which makes me wonder who really cares about this problem. Nursing is a hard job that takes not only a willingness to do many not so pleasant tasks but also alot of common sense, knowledge of drugs/diseases/treatments and a strong back for all that lifting, pulling and pushing. I applaud anyone with the heart, skill and smarts for the job and it makes me sick to see these kids not only "rejected" by the schools but actually told to change their major! WOW! I guess when the folks making the rules are the ones lying in the bed waiting for the nurse to bring the pain medicine or explain what the heck the doctor just said they may just change their tune.
I encourage all these kids to keep with it and get your degree in nursing. I still enjoy my work after 20 years and get so much satisfaction from helping folks when the going gets tough. Nursing is so much more than most people realize.

Posted by srascon on April 21, 2008 at 3:30 p.m. (Suggest removal)

How about retired nurses (receiving pensions therefore do not need top pay) teaching the classes. Who better to teach aspiring nurses.

Posted by dpgerman on April 21, 2008 at 7:54 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Srascon,
It's refreshing to see a viable solution.... are you volunteering?
But it is true that pouring money into all the various "studies" programs is taking away from degree programs that will do more for the world in the long run.
I read recently about a new "Diversity Studies" program being run by a PhD at a Virginia state university. It made me think of the fact that I have lived in a very integrated neighborhood for most of the last 30 years. There is no need for a degree of any level to learn to be neighborly; but it takes a college education to be a nurse.
Let's put the money where it will do the most good. Enough of the "underwater basket weaving" degrees!

Posted by ReadMyLipsNoNewTaxes on April 22, 2008 at 8:16 a.m. (Suggest removal)

"How about retired nurses (receiving pensions therefore do not need top pay) teaching the classes. Who better to teach aspiring nurses."

LOL, a pension? Nurses do not get pensions what do you think they are cops?

Posted by lizlemon on April 23, 2008 at 6:27 a.m. (Suggest removal)

bearbigdog2: You are correct that CMH is planning on updating their facilities.However, they are not adding any additional patient beds. Without the increase in patient beds, there won't be measurable increase in nursing staff.

Posted by lizlemon on April 23, 2008 at 6:33 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Readmylipsnonewtaxes is 100% right. Nurses do not get pensions. In addition, to teach at the university level, a Master's degree is necessary which requires two things: funds for education and INCREASED pay for an advanced degree. Looks like were in a catch-22.

Posted by marketrealist on April 23, 2008 at 8:54 a.m. (Suggest removal)

The crisis in the California education system is attributable to the penal system which is increasingly gobbling up resources. We have 1 in 100 people in jail today. To put that person in jail, we have an infrastructure of police (patrol cops, dispatchers...), courts (judges, lawyers, clerks...), jails (guards, cooks, cleaners...), and parole (officers, clerks...). This massive infrastructure is expensive as many of these security related jobs have high retirement costs and insurance costs. The cost to keep a prisoner in jail is about $40,000. How many California tax payers would need to pay taxes to keep that one person in jail? My guess is about 10 households. If 1 percent is in jail, you do the math. Taxpayers are supporting a huge and unsustainable expense. Now, worse than that, is that once someone goes to jail, they learn bad habbits beings around pretty tough criminals so are more likely to go back to jail. In addition, many employers do background checks and won't hire parolees. Its a self sustaining business.

Taxpayers need to revolt. Its time to relook at sentencing for petty crimes and divert people away from the jails. This is especially true for drug users who should not be in jail but in treatment. Most Western Europe has a 1 in 1000 in jail compared to our 1 in 100. The train is heading for wreck. Can we stop it from crashing?





Article discussions on this site are to support community debates of issues related to our stories and editorials.

Discussions should not stray from the subject of the story or editorial.

We do not allow the following:

  • Posts that degrade others on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation or disability.
  • Disparaging remarks, abusive language or obscene comments.
  • Threats, whether obvious or veiled.

We reserve the right to delete threads and/or ban users for these or other reasons we deem necessary.

Opinions are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Discuss this article
(Requires free registration.)

Username:

Password:
(Forgotten your password?)

Your Turn:

Please download the latest version of Adobe Flash Player, or enable JavaScript for your browser to view the video player.