Home › Entertainment › Movies
Ben Stein drops any pretense of funny in attack on evolution
'Expelled' tries to frame issue as lost freedom
'Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed'
1/2 of a star out of four
With Ben Stein and Richard Dawkins.
A Rampant Films production directed by Nathan Frankowski. Produced by Logan Craft and Walt Ruloff. Written by Stein, Ruloff and Kevin Miller. 90 minutes. PG for thematic material, some disturbing images and brief smoking.
Droning funnyman Ben Stein monkeys around with evolution with the new documentary, "Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed," a cynical attempt to sucker Christian conservatives into thinking they're losing the "intelligent design" debate because of academic "prejudice."
"Expelled" is a full-on, amply budgeted Michael Moore-styled mockery of evolution, a film that dresses creationist crackpottery in an "intelligent design" leisure suit and tries to make the fact that it's not given credence in schools a matter of "academic freedom."
Using loaded language and loaded imagery, Stein and Co. (Nathan Frankowski is the credited director) equate evolution with atheism, lay responsibility for the Holocaust at the feet of Charles Darwin, interview and creatively edit biologists and others (scientists "cast" for their eccentric appearance) to make them look foolish for insisting that science, not religion, can explain creation.
Stein and friends use animation (shades of "Bowling for Columbine"), amusing chunks of B-movies and even "The Wizard of Oz" and classic propaganda techniques to undercut 150 years of peer-tested research. Their goal? Create just a sliver of doubt about evolution. It's a classic Big Tobacco/"Inconvenient Truth" denial tactic.
All the loaded references to Stalin, communism et al reminded me of Khrushchev's famous challenge to the West, "We will bury you," meaning that communism would use the very precepts of Western democracy and capitalism to weaken and break us. Stein and friends use scientists' need to speak in terms of probabilities, rather than absolutes, to undercut a scientific theorem that withstands test after test, from Darwin to the Scopes monkey trial.
Stein, a Nixon administration functionary who reinvented himself as a movie and TV buffoon after "Ferris Bueller's Day Off," seems closer to his latter persona in this disingenuous and dishonest film about something so silly you really wonder if he himself believes it. Or is the former host of "Win Ben Stein's Money" just trying to add to Ben Stein's money at the expense of the gullible? Perhaps that's why he's been so determined to keep his movie from anyone who might not automatically buy into its thesis, hiding it, in effect, from most members of the press.
Shockingly, the "experts" Stein hurls up against evolution are disgruntled, undercredentialed academics dismissed from lesser colleges, they say, because they wanted to teach creation rather than science. Other "experts" in the film come from anti-evolution "think tank" cranks and a Pole who invites nothing so much as a really good Polish joke.
Credentialed scientists who also describe themselves as Christian have attacked the film for suggesting they are persecuted for their beliefs. They say they aren't. Others interviewed for the film have complained of dishonest editing, misrepresentations and about not having the pleasure of having actually met Stein.
When he blurts out in one "interview" — apparently he didn't actually sit and confront some of these people himself, the film is just edited that way — "Where's the data?" you can almost hear him choke on the irony.
Where's your data, Ben? Got any? Any at all? Anyone else? Anyone? Anyone?
"Expelled" relies on the viewer's inability or unwillingness to wrestle with a complex corner of science, double-talking its way toward a "must be a miracle" solution to anything that science may not claim to have an answer for. Dismiss that for having no basis in fact, and you're infringing on "academic freedom."
That's not it at all, Ben. And really, when academia, the courts, the opinions of the educated have all weighed in on this subject on that "other side," who's the real monkey in this "debate"?
— Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.




Posted by theonlycapsfan on April 24, 2008 at 7:46 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Wow. If that wasn't a total one-sided, biased review of this movie, I don't know what is. In light of having just seen this film, I can just smile, shake my head, and say without a shadow of a doubt...Roger Moore didn't get it. In fact, he is only further proving Ben Stein's point in the movie.
Roger, honestly...you TOTALLY missed the point of the film.
Ben Stein's point was not to debate evolution versus intelligent design...his point is that there are no debates allowed unless you want to lose your credibility and tenure as a scientist/professor.
It's not about proving one over the other...it's about the freedom to even have the discussion in the first place. There is no freedom. That's the point.
Watch it again Roger...
(Requires free registration.)
Article discussions on this site are to support community debates of issues related to our stories and editorials.
Discussions should not stray from the subject of the story or editorial.
We do not allow the following:
We reserve the right to delete threads and/or ban users for these or other reasons we deem necessary.
Opinions are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.