Weather | Beachcam
Login | Contact Us | Staff | Site Map | Archives | Alerts | Electronic Edition | Subscribe to the paper

HomeBusinessBusiness

Potential for real estate fraud grows as more homeowners face foreclosure

Mortgage help can come with a catch


Download Podcast  Download this story as a podcast!

Steve Greenberg
Star staff

Movie Trailer:

"Predatory Practices" - 3 min.
A film about the growth of mortgage fraud in the United States.

Watch trailer now >>

Homeowner tips

- Don't pay upfront fees to "foreclosure rescue" companies that promise to help you keep your property.

- Don't sign your deed over without consulting a lawyer you trust. Simply signing your deed over doesn't formally release you from your mortgage liability.

- Don't sign any contract to sell your home until you review the document with a lawyer.

- Don't work with anyone who discourages you from contacting your mortgage company, refuses to put promises in writing, pressures you to sign paperwork you haven't had a chance to read thoroughly or fills out paperwork for you.

- Contact your lender at the first sign of financial trouble. See if the loan can be restructured or refinanced, or work out a repayment plan. Keep in mind that most lenders don't want to foreclose because it costs them money.

- Consider selling your home if you have equity in it. If all other options fail, you also might consider deeding your property back to your mortgage company, also known as deed-in-lieu of foreclosure.

- Contact a reputable nonprofit credit and housing counselor if you are not able to work with your lender. For a list of approved housing counselors, call the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development at 800-569-4287 or go to http://www.hud.gov. Click on the foreclosure link.

- For information on mortgage practices, complaints, compliance or advertisements, contact the Mortgage Lending unit in the state Department of Real Estate at 916-227-0770.

- If you believe that you are victim of real estate fraud, call the Ventura County District Attorney's office at 662-1750, or download a complaint form, in English or Spanish, at http://da.countyofventura.org/refraud_unit.htm.

Raleigh News & Observer; Ventura County District Attorney

Common real estate scams

Bailout: A scammer offers to buy a home for much less than its value, with the understanding that the owner can rent it and eventually repurchase it if certain terms are met. However, the monthly payment or repurchase price is typically inflated, making it impossible for a person to buy back the home. Eventually, the property is forfeited and the new owner sells the home at market value and pockets the equity.

Fake home sale: In this scheme, a scammer says he will buy the home to get control of the deed or title to the home. In some cases, homeowners believe that their lender has been paid but don't get proof before handing over the deed. But the homeowners are still liable for the mortgage because they have merely signed over the deed, not sold the home. The scammer rents the home to a tenant with an option to buy pocketing any down payment and rent but never making a mortgage payment. Eventually, the lender notifies the owner that it is foreclosing on the property. The deed holder walks away with no liability.

Bogus help: This scheme is simple and common. The scammer promises to save the homeowners' credit or get them low monthly payments. Instead, the homeowner pay thousands of dollars in fees, and the scammer does nothing. In the end, the homeowner still might be forced into foreclosure or bankruptcy.

Raleigh News & Observer

If you've recently received a mailer from a company that touts that it can pay off your home in five days, don't get too excited.

The potential for real estate fraud has soared, driven by a surge in default notices sent to thousands of struggling California homeowners during the past several months.

There are an increased number of scammers posing as "foreclosure consultants," said Phillip Ihde, manager of the southern region of the state Department of Real Estate, in charge of investigative operations.

Real estate scams prey on the trust of people in desperate situations. These so-called foreclosure consultants make false promises, giving homeowners the impression that they can improve their credit or pay off their properties in full, with the intent to swindle homeowners out of large amounts of money or, in some cases, their homes.

It happened to Maria Pastor in November 2002. When she met Edgar Berrazueta, she thought that "he was a decent person, a kind person," she said in Spanish on a video "Predatory Practices," created by Walk Your Talk Productions.

Pastor was told that after refinancing, her mortgage payments would be $650 per month on her Oxnard residence. She realized that something was wrong when she and her daughter began looking over the loan documents. She couldn't figure out the new monthly payment — if it would be lowered or if it would adjust each month.

"The next thing I knew, I received the letter from the loan company that I was going to leave my house ... that I could no longer stay here," Pastor says on the video. "He took $23,000 out of my home and didn't give me one penny."

In this instance and others, Berrazueta arranged "cash-out" refinance loans, but concealed it from his clients, intercepted the cash-out checks and deposited them into his bank account, according to the Ventura County District Attorney's Office. In August 2005, he was sentenced to three years and eight months in prison.

As the market slows, dozens of Internet-based companies have launched to capitalize on homeowners' inability to pay their mortgages. Companies advertise that they can provide cash for homes, within days or even hours of when an applicant submits an online form.

Some companies offer a completely lawful transaction; others do not, said Miles Weiss, senior deputy district attorney for Ventura County.

"With any Internet-based promotion, you should be extremely cautious," he said. "That level of caution should rise if you're in a precarious position financially. If you're on the edge of losing your home, you have to realize there are shady operations and there are legitimate (ones)."

Even if it's a legitimate cash offer, investors who make these purchases are seeking to buy at least 20 percent below market value, Weiss said.

Making a profit is a factor

Profit is obviously a driving factor, said Ira Friedman, president of FastPropertyBuyer.com, a Woodland Hills real estate investment company. If the company cannot make a profit on the purchase, it isn't interested.

Not all real estate investment firms that advertise to pay cash for homes are in it for a quick con. At FastPropertyBuyer.com, Friedman emphasizes that the purchase price will be fair and sufficient, and that the company does not make false promises. The company's investors have made at least 1,200 real estate purchases in California in the past 30 years, in excess of $250 million, he said.

"The difference between us and the other companies out there is that we have the actual cash to buy the property," Friedman said. "Ninety-nine percent of the companies out there take the leads and sell them to little investors around the country."

The firm doesn't claim to hand out cash hours after an online form is submitted, either. Friedman says a typical transaction takes about two to three weeks to close.

In the past two months, the site's inquiries have doubled, Friedman said. The company follows through on purchases on about 5 percent to 10 percent of the inquiries. Many are from owners who owe more on their homes than what they're worth, and are sometimes as much as six months behind on their payments. The firm buys real estate worth millions of dollars every month. Many recent transactions have been short sales, which are becoming more prevalent, Friedman said.

A short sale is when the buyer pays less than what the homeowner owes on the mortgage.

When dealing with a drastic, life-altering decision, Weiss says it's worth it for homeowners to pay an attorney $200 an hour for a consultation.

"People are so leery to pay a couple of hundred bucks, but I think it's just foolhardy not to get a qualified attorney to help with the transaction," he said. "An attorney will have only one allegiance, and that's to his client. You need to have someone just in your corner."

Fraud in Ventura County has always existed; now, it's a matter of how much it bubbles to the surface, Weiss said.

"It's definitely a growing problem," he said. "Unfortunately, I think it's going to get worse as the market toughens up, because of the lack of ability to refinance or sell, and with homeowners being upside down on their mortgages."

There were 102 complaints of real estate fraud filed by Ventura County residents in 2006, Weiss said. Of those cases, 54 were rejected as "not constituting of criminal conduct."

The unit documented 113 victims in 2006 and filed charges against eight defendants accused of real estate fraud. The dollar losses for those cases were in excess of $4 million.

The District Attorney's Office now has at least 38 cases pending criminal investigation.

Many scams not reported

While the number of complaints are rising, there are still uncountable scams that go unreported.

"There is a definite hesitation by people to not report misconduct that can be due to ignorance or cultural fears, related to legal consequences," Weiss said. "For example, an undocumented person may believe all that will happen if they complain is them being deported. We see suspects using that type of fear to intimidate these types of victims from not coming forward."

Once a notice of default is filed, it becomes public record and recipients become easy targets.

In Ventura County, notices of default on houses and condominiums jumped to 965 in the first quarter, up 123 percent from 433 over the same period a year ago. Defaults are the first step in a lengthy process leading to foreclosure.

During the first quarter this year, there were 203 foreclosures in Ventura County, up from 17 over the same period a year ago, according to DataQuick Information Systems, a La Jolla marketing information firm that tracks real estate.

"Now everyone under the sun has a rescue plan for the person facing foreclosure," Weiss said. "The borrower is in a potentially precarious situation, probably financially strapped, looking for any type of relief."

Meanwhile, there aren't a lot of rescue options — a homeowner facing foreclosure can either sell or refinance if there's equity. But in many cases, those bailout steps aren't possible. It leaves some struggling homeowners vulnerable to anyone who comes up with a different plan.

"If it sounds too good to be true, it is," Ihde told a crowd of 300 mostly real estate professionals during a fraud awareness forum at the Residence Inn by Marriott in Oxnard on April 20.

Qualifications checked out

The market slowdown is a precursor to reports of real estate fraud, Ihde said. When lenders see loans come back to them, they scrutinize the borrower's qualifications.

On the flip side, buyers, anxious to blame someone for a poor decision on a loan, are more apt to tell on the bad banks if the situation turns ugly.

"When they're making money, they don't report it, but when they're in a bad situation, they report it," Ihde said.

Some buyers attempting to get as much house as possible got a loan with the lowest payment possible, Ihde said. Reporting false income on loan documents has become a major concern as defaults rise.

Borrowers who had reported an artificially inflated income to qualify for a loan said they were told that banks don't care — that everyone does it, and that it's the only way to get approved for a loan, Ihde said.

"Well, I'm here to tell you that banks do care, especially when they're being investigated," Ihde said.

Unusual insights

Retailers use price-optimization software to assess tricky issues and often uncover results no human would likely find on a spreadsheet. A sampling, gathered from interviews with retailers and software vendors:

- A few years ago, 7-Eleven Inc. noticed that when it fought to "beat down" certain costs, so its convenience stores could reduce some of the prices they charged consumers, the effort wasn't always worthwhile, says Kay Trapp, manager for merchandise pricing. It turned out that several items with newly lowered prices saw no change in sales. The chain bought price-optimization software to get such insights in advance. "We decided it made us smarter," Trapp says.

- Like many national companies, an electronics retailer priced batteries the same all over. Until SAP's Khimetrics software showed that consumers in Dallas were generally willing to pay more for batteries than people in Boston. The data revealed another strange twist: The battery that had the highest "price sensitivity" in Dallas had the lowest price sensitivity in Boston. In other words, while Texans would buy this particular battery only within a narrow price range, Bostonians were far less picky about it. The store altered its prices accordingly, sold more batteries and made more money at it.

- A grocery retailer charged high prices for ice cream, but frequently offered deep discounts. Consumers largely bought ice cream only during the promotions. Khimetrics advised reducing the regular price of ice cream and running fewer sales. Eventually revenue and profits rose and presumably pleased consumers who stopped trying to stock their freezers whenever a sale was on.

- In a store with an array of paintbrushes, the best-seller was its cheapest one, at $1. But DemandTec suggested that the store stop selling the item altogether. The software showed that would help the store sell more of its higher-priced (and more profitable) paintbrushes because the key factor in paintbrush sales was whether a customer was buying paint, not the price of a brush.

The Associated Press

Discussions

There are 6 comments to this article.   

Comments are found beneath the Yahoo! ad below.

Comments

Posted by mike1981 on April 29, 2007 at 7:45 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Government authorities and legal services attorneys and private attorneys who represent scam victims are battling foreclosure rescue scams all over the country. To see other stories, go to The Home Equity Theft Reporter, link at:

http://HomeEquityTheft.blogspot.com

and then click "Foreclosure Rescue Posts" in the sidebar on the right side of the page.

Posted by windeecity on April 29, 2007 at 11:32 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Over the past several months I have yet to see any success stories on the growing mortgage crisis.

Is there anyone out there that actually lowered their payments with a re-structured loan, saved thier home from foreclosure or even got thier lender to respond to them? We didn't even get the promised loan rework package mailed to us. Now 4 weeks later things are worse. Thank you Countrywide for putting false hope in us and not following through.

If I read one more article that states to call your lender before it's too late...well just remember We did and no one cared.

Posted by nowwadrudoin on April 29, 2007 at 7 p.m. (Suggest removal)

This whole run-up in prices was caused by GREED and crazy credit....All of these VICTIMS just saw $s in their eyes when they signed the contract...thinking that they were so smart and gloating with their cashout refi's, HELOC's, and buying all the toys...Well, the hangover is just beginning and deal with it...With over 60 lenders out and prices deflating rapidly with tightening credit and STAGFLATION this is not going to end nicely...

Posted by ed.fitzhenry on April 30, 2007 at 7:12 a.m. (Suggest removal)

No one signed the loan paperwork but the borrower. Why on earth would anyone buy an extremely overpriced home at the peak of the market? Because their realtor told them that they would be priced out of the market forever, because the market can only go up. Realtors, being the chronic optimists that they are, still will not admit that the market is in decline. They blame it on "seasonal lulls," or "bad weather." It's true, look at the National ASSociation of Realtors' website. It is strewn with denial.
No one will ever prove that greedy realtors and mortgage brokers created this situation, but they did. The buyers, however, are equally to blame for believing what their realtors and mortgage brokers told them. The realtors and mortgage brokers walk away with their fat commission checks, and the buyers get foreclosed upon. It doesn't seem fair.
Soon, buyers will be able to buy whatever they want, for the price they want, and the realtors and mortgage brokers, the ones not doing it already, will be begging on the side of the road, or working at the local carwash.

Posted by nowwadrudoin on April 30, 2007 at 7:26 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Also, how many of these Realtors were the actual speculators and also we must include the PHANTOM bidders in this catastrophic Ponzi scheme...This is just the beginning of a roller-coaster ride in free fall mode with a few dead cat bounces on the way down...Just wait until mortgage rates get to a normalcy rate from the 40 YEAR LOW we have seen the last 4 years...18 percent mortgage rates during the last STAGFLATION of the 70's would really cause a problem...Hmmm with the GDP at a low rate and inflation rising without the help of energy or food in the mix of the figure, this is the perfect storm...Good Luck to all the SMART GREEDY ONES

Posted by nowwadrudoin on May 1, 2007 at 5:15 a.m. (Suggest removal)

At least LIAReah is going to be gone...about time





Article discussions on this site are to support community debates of issues related to our stories and editorials.

Discussions should not stray from the subject of the story or editorial.

We do not allow the following:

  • Posts that degrade others on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation or disability.
  • Disparaging remarks, abusive language or obscene comments.
  • Threats, whether obvious or veiled.

We reserve the right to delete threads and/or ban users for these or other reasons we deem necessary.

Opinions are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Discuss this article
(Requires free registration.)

Username:

Password:
(Forgotten your password?)

Your Turn:

Please download the latest version of Adobe Flash Player, or enable JavaScript for your browser to view the video player.